May 13, 2015
Thomas More star Sydney Moss is the only player in Division III women's basketball history to sweep player of the year honors, win the NCAA Tournament Most Outstanding Player award, play for the national champion and simultaneously lead Division III in scoring. But the bolded type shows other players who have their names in three of those categories.
* - denotes a year in which a tournament Most Outstanding Player was not selected.
| Year |
Player of the Year |
Tournament MOP |
National champion |
Regular season scoring champ (tournament result) |
| 2016 | Sydney Moss (D3hoops & WBCA) | Sydney Moss, Thomas More | Thomas More (33-0) | Marajiah Bacon, Kean (None) |
| 2015 | Sydney Moss (D3hoops & WBCA) | Sydney Moss, Thomas More | Thomas More (33-0) | Sydney Moss, Thomas More (national champs) |
| 2014 | Sydney Moss (D3hoops & WBCA) | Kyra Dayon, FDU-Florham | FDU-Florham (33-0) | Sydney Moss, Thomas More (Elite 8) |
| 2013 | Carissa Verkaik, Calvin (D3hoops) Sam Barber, UW-Stevens Point (WBCA) |
Ellie Pearson, DePauw | DePauw (34-0) | Ashley Montecchio, Rosemont (None) |
| 2012 | Olivia Lett, Ill. Wesleyan (D3hoops) Caroline Stedman, Amherst (WBCA) |
Olivia Lett, Illinois Wesleyan | Illinois Wesleyan (28-5) | Karin Bird, Thomas (None) |
| 2011 | Chelsie Schweers, CNU (D3hoops) Jaci Daigneault, Amherst (WBCA) |
Caroline Stedman, Amherst | Amherst (32-1) | Chelsie Schweers, CNU (Final Four) |
| 2010 | Carrie Snikkers, Hope (D3hoops & WBCA) |
Jaimie McFarlin, Washington U. | Washington U. (29-2) | Kimberly Blakney, Farmingdale State (1st round) |
| 2009 | Hillary Klimowicz, TCNJ (D3hoops & WBCA) |
Kristen Schielee, George Fox | George Fox (32-0) | Kimberly Blakney, Farmingdale State (None) |
| 2008 | Meia Daniels, Howard Payne (D3hoops & WBCA) |
Meia Daniels, Howard Payne | Howard Payne (33-0) | Lindsay Ippel, Millikin (None) |
| 2007 | Ashley Marble, Southern Maine (D3hoops) Eileen Flaherty, Bowdoin (WBCA) |
Liz Bondi, DePauw | DePauw (31-3) | Lindsay Ippel, Millikin (None) |
| 2006 | Megan Silva, Randolph-Macon (D3hoops & WBCA) |
Bria Ebels, Hope | Hope (33-1) | Megan Silva, Randolph-Macon (Elite 8) |
| 2005 | Amanda Nechuta, UW-Stevens Point (WBCA/1st team D3hoops) |
Joanna Conner, Millikin | Millikin (29-2) | Camille Manning, NYC Tech (None) |
| 2004 | Allison Coleman, Eastern Conn. (WBCA/1st team D3hoops) |
Tara Rausch, Wilmington | Wilmington (27-6) | Camille Manning, NYC Tech (None) |
| 2003 | Kendra Anderson, Hardin-Simmons (WBCA/1st team D3hoops) |
Allison Wooley, Trinity (Texas) | Trinity (Texas) (28-5) | Tiffany Trent, Cazenovia (None) |
| 2002 | Meredith Eisenhut, St. Lawrence (WBCA/4th team D3hoops) |
Carry Boehning, UW-Stevens Point | UW-Stevens Point (30-3) | E'Lisa Ladson, Wesleyan, Ga. (None) |
| 2001 | Tasha Rodgers, Wash. U (WBCA/1st team D3hoops) |
Tasha Rodgers, Washington U. | Washington U. (28-2) | Emily Mullet, Eastern Mennonite (None) Angie Ensley, Cedar Crest (None) |
| 2000 | Alia Fischer, Wash. U (WBCA/1st team D3hoops) |
Alia Fischer, Washington U. | Washington U. (30-0) | Tara Carleton, Randolph (None) |
| 1999 | Alia Fischer, Wash. U (WBCA/2nd team D3hoops) |
*Fischer was All-Tournament | Washington U. (30-0) | Ronda Jo Miller, Gallaudet (Sweet 16) |
| 1998 | Alia Fischer, Wash. U (WBCA/1st team D3hoops) |
Amy Schweizer, Washington U. | Washington U. (28-2) | Glenda Gilieud, Stillman (None) |
| 1997 | Corinne Carson, Marymount (WBCA) | Marsha Harris, NYU | NYU (29-1) | Meegan Garrity, Clark (1st round) |
| 1996 | Wendy Wangerin, UW-Oshkosh (WBCA) | *Wangerin was All-Tournament | UW-Oshkosh (31-0) | Meegan Garrity, Clark (None) |
| 1995 | Emilie Hanson, Central (WBCA) | * | Capital (33-0) | Emilie Hanson, Central (2nd round) |
| 1994 | Laura Schmelzer, Capital (WBCA) | *Schmelzer was All-Tournament | Capital (30-1) | Emilie Hanson, Central (2nd round) |
| 1993 | Laurie Trow, St. Thomas | * | Central (24-5) | Sladja Kovijanic, Middlebury (None) |
| 1992 | Kathy Beck, Moravian | *Beck was All-Tournament | Alma (24-3) | Missy Hensley, Eastern Mennonite (None) |
| 1991 | Ann Gilbert, Oberlin | * | St. Thomas (29-2) | Missy Sharer, Grinnell (None) |
| 1990 | Susan Heidt, St. John Fisher | *Heidt was All-Tournament | Hope (24-2) | Anna Gilbert, Oberlin (None) |
| 1989 | Kirsten Elizabeth Dunford, CSU-Stanislaus | *Dunford was All-Tournament | Elizabethtown (29-2) | Lisa Halloran, Farmingdale State (None) |
| 1988 | Kirsten Elizabeth Dunford, CSU-Stanislaus | * | Concordia-Moorhead (29-2) | Catie Cleary, Pine Manor (None) |
| 1987 | Shelly Parks, Scranton | * | UW-Stevens Point (27-2) | Jeannie Demers, Buena Vista (None) |
| 1986 | Jane Meyer, Elizabethtown | * | Salem State (29-1) | Jeannie Demers, Buena Vista (None) |
| 1985 | Deanna Kyle, Scranton | *Kyle was All-Tournament | Scranton (31-1) | Jeannie Demers, Buena Vista (1st round) |
| 1984 | Page Lutz, Elizabethtown | Page Lutz, Elizabethtown | Rust (26-5) | Laura Johnson, Shenandoah (None) |
| 1983 | Margie O'Brien, Clark | Page Lutz, Elizabethtown | North Central, Ill. (26-6) | Jodie Imbrie, Grove City (Sweet 16) |
| 1982 | None selected | Bev Hall, Elizabethtown | Elizabethtown (26-1) | Mary Beth Bowler, King's (None) |